A Bishop’s Thoughts on G.S.2022 in Australia

Dr. Peter Stuart. Bishop of the Diocese of Newcastle, N.S.W., Australia, has issued the following Pastoral Letter to his diocese, following on from an earlier one in which he re-affirmed the Newcastle diocese’s intention to continue listening to the concerns of LGBT+ people in the diocese. It was in imitation of this eirenic stance that the House of Bishops at the Australian General Sydney declined to support a Motion from the Sydney Diocese that would have outlawed the Blessing of a Same-Sex Married Couple. Here is an extract from Bishop Peter’s earlier Pastoral Letter to his diocese.

“In our present age LGBTIQA+ people and their allies have spoken fully and openly of their continued sense of rejection by cultural, family, and religious communities as a direct contributor to their sense of poor well-being leading to self-harm, suicide risk, and suicide. We are listening to this. We can take practical action in our communities to minister with genuine welcome, care, and partnership in the Gospel. We can commit ourselves to ensuring that none of our ministry and mission is a cause of further alienation and harm. We must also acknowledge that there are attitudes, behaviours, and practices in churches which, have led and lead to long-lasting harm because of the way spiritual and pastoral power is used or perceived to be used.”

It is now known that the Diocese of Sydney (which has 28% representation in the General Synod (as opposed to the 4% of the Newcastle Diocese) – after the rejection of the Motion by the House of Bishops – was active in promoting a conservative’s petition containing a note of censure on the House of Bishops for not going along with Sydney’s intended Declaration of Marriage as solely the union between a male and a female, and the only context for human sexual expression.

Nothing to date is known of the effect of that petition. In any event, as Bishop Peter has pointed out; no diocese of the Australian Anglican Church has, de facto, to automatically implement any decision of General Synod – without the consent of the local Synod. This means, in effect, that the Newcastle (and any other Australian) Diocese may go ahead with the Blessing of a Civilly married couple if the local Diocesan Synod so chooses in its own Constitution.

If the Sydney-sponsored ‘Declaration’ had been affirmed by the House of Bishops at General Synod, this would have further exacerbated the ethos of sexism and homophobia in the Church that most of the Australian dioceses wish to extinguish for the pastoral wellbeing of ALL God’s children.

Father Ron Smith, Christchurch, New Zealand


13 May 2022
Dear friends in Christ,
General Synod 2022
I am writing to you as the 18th General Synod draws to a close. I have enjoyed the opportunity of being with each of the 4 clergy and 4 lay representatives from our Diocese as we have sat,deliberated, ate, and prayed together. Archdeacon Arthur Copeman, Dean Katherine Bowyer, and I have all been elected to the General Synod Standing Committee. Arthur, Katherine, and Ms Sue Williams have been active in the administration of the Synod. Several of us spoke in debates and joined in out-of-session conversations.

The rhythm of each day has been shaped by the Eucharist, Morning Prayer, Bible Study and Evening Prayer. Brother Christopher John SSF from Stroud and the Reverend Mandy Wheatley TSSF, formerly from the Diocese, were part of the Synod Chaplaincy Team. Dr Di Rayson, a first-time representative of our Diocese, wonderfully led, the Wednesday bible study.

With a common mind, the General Synod has continued to ensure the safety of all people in churches and addressed Climate Change, Family Violence, Aged and Disability Care, Gambling, Veteran Suicide, Euthanasia, Palliative Care, and the viability of regional dioceses. It offered an apology where it has treated LGBTI people with disrespect, abuse or bullying and expressed again its commitmentthat all churches and ministries are welcoming, safe, and respectful. It reflected on and prayed about the war in the Ukraine.

The General Synod is run with a parliamentary model. We have questions, petitions, bills, and motions. There are two dominant factions roughly represented by a 66:34 breakdown. There are around 250 members. The Diocese of Sydney comprises 28% of the Synod. The Diocese of Newcastle under 4%.

The Anglican Church of Australia is different to the Church of England, or the Church in New Zealand, where the decisions of the General Synod are binding on a Diocese. In Australia, no decision affecting the order and government of a Diocese comes into effect unless decided by that Diocese. When our Synod meets in September, there will be several Canons from General Synod to consider. Last night, 40% of the Synod voted to affirm same-sex marriage as part of Christian life and witness, 60% voted against it. Our Diocesan Synod has never considered this question. It has only considered
blessing a civil same-sex marriage.

Formally, the views of the House of Bishops have only been evident on three matters before the Synod – a statement on unchastity, a statement on marriage, and changes to the Canon concerning Services 1992. With both other houses, the House of Bishops affirmed the statement on unchastity and declined to change the Canon concerning Services. The House of Bishops did not support the statement on marriage. It was evident in the Synod that the statement did not find wide agreement.
This weighed heavily on many Bishops.

We heard of same sex attracted Christians who live chaste and celibate lives who do not feel respected by a debate that presumes that all same sex attracted people wish to marry or engage in sexual activity. We heard of same sex attracted Christians who want to marry in Church. We heard contested reflections of the scriptures. We heard that 1/3 of worshipping Anglicans are single and we heard a call to affirm singleness as an honourable and blessed state. We heard that very few blessings of same sex civil marriages had occurred since any possible obstacle was removed in November 2019. We heard a plea to continue slowly, pastorally, and faithfully.

The fact of disagreement or continued questioning does not close but rather invites further deliberation. Significant theological, pastoral, and missional dialogue will continue. The first Christians and the early Church wrestled with many weighty matters as the Church has done through the ages. In every age, we seek the wisdom and guidance of God. We can be encouraged and edified by the ongoing conversations in our Diocese and those that will occur at our Diocesan Synod in September.

Our Diocese has a profound responsibility and opportunity to witness to the grace and love of God, from the Hawkesbury River to Lake Cathie, from the coast and beyond the Burning Mountain. We can contribute well to human flourishing through our work. We can change lives by witnessing to Jesus Christ, who continues to inspire us. Through our parishes, agencies and schools, we are making a significant difference in people’s lives, expressing the mission of Christ, and playing our part in enabling God’s will to be done on earth as in heaven.

May we continue to be renewed in our Godly communion with one another. Please be assured of my prayers for all that you are and in all that you do.

Yours sincerely in Christ,
Dr Peter Stuart
Bishop of Newcastle

About kiwianglo

Retired Anglican priest, living in Christchurch, New Zealand. Ardent supporter of LGBT Community, and blogger on 'Thinking Anglicans UK' site. Theology: liberal, Anglo-Catholic & traditional. regarding each person as a unique expression of Christ, and therefore lovable.
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.