Nun challenges church – stop suppressing Catholic reform

  1. CathNews NZ Pacific
  2. Thursday, May 20th, 2021
  • A prominent US Benedictine nun is warning Australia’s Catholic Church to stop suppressing Catholic reform from its ordinary members or face an inevitable decline.

This is not the first time Sister Joan Chittister has called out Australia’s Catholic hierarchy. She was recently embroiled in a censorship row with Melbourne’s Archbishop.

Now she is renewing calls for women’s ordination and for laypeople to be given more power over parishes.

Chittister’s challenging call comes at at time when the nation’s bishops are under pressure to overhaul the church after years of sex scandals and internal unrest.

Reforms such as these are were meant to be thrashed out at this year’s Plenary Council, which is scheduled to take place in October.

Said to be the most significant conference Australian Catholic bishops have held in 80 years, the working documents prepared for the event suggest some of the more contentious issues on the agenda may not get a full hearing – if they are discussed at all.

“Everyone knows that the church in Australia needs a major overhaul of its governance, culture and structures, but instead of setting out a clear, concise and coherent blueprint for reform, this document is a ground plan for inertia,” says Catholics for Renewal president Peter Wilkinson.

“It is very disappointing.”

Chittister says she shares concerns that suppressing Catholic reform “by the bishops” would impede much-needed improvements.

The upshot will be that ever more people will abandon their parishes.

“There are one of two ways that this can end. The bishops can embrace the concerns and the need for resolution or they continue to ignore the laity – at which point the church will some day wake up in the morning and find out that the church is in fact gone,” she says.

Speaking to an audience of 3000 this month, she added: “Catholicism must grow up, beyond the parochial to the global, beyond one system and one tradition to a broader way of looking at life … Why not married priests, women priests, or women cardinals?”

Chittister’s appearance in Australia comes at a critical moment for the church ahead of the upcoming Plenary Council.

Expectations were high in the wake of the Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Abuse, which found the hierarchical nature of the church, coupled with its lack of governance, had created “a culture of deferential obedience” in which the protection of paedophile priests was left unchallenged.

Whether the Church actually has a will to change is something Catholic Australia has yet to find out. It is reportedly concerned that change is not on the agenda.

Their fears were compounded in March when a working document prepared for the Plenary Council did not give enough credence to critical issues that members have been seeking to address.

Peter Johnstone, who is the head of the Australasian Catholic Coalition for Church Reform, is urging Australia’s bishops to use the Plenary Council to genuinely tackle the “existential crisis” the church faces.

Source : Brisbane Times


Sister Joan Chittester is a well-known American Roman Catholic Religious (OS.B.), whose faithfulness to the reforming zeal of Pope John XXIII’s Second Vatican Council teachings is legendary – both in her own country and around the world.

The Australian Catholic Church – like that in the U.S.A. – is (according to Sister Joan) behind the times in resisting the reformative ethos of the Catholic Church at Vatican II.

At a time when Australian Catholics are still reeling from the stories of abuse by prominent clergy, that have not yet been thoroughly investigated, this doughty Nun will have stirred up some discomfort among those bishops and clergy who are still reluctant to bring the Church into the 21st Century.

Having been invited to address a Conference by prominent laity in the Australian Church – with a view to ‘shaking up’ what she (and they) see as a spirit of inertia, refusing to adapt to the new intiiatives of Pope Francis – to re-invigorate both clergy and laity with the energy of Christ’s mission to the world; Sister Joan seems, from this article, to have achieved that objective.

“Come Holy Spirit, renew the hearts of your people with the Fire of you Love!”. Amen

About kiwianglo

Retired Anglican priest, living in Christchurch, New Zealand. Ardent supporter of LGBT Community, and blogger on 'Thinking Anglicans UK' site. Theology: liberal, Anglo-Catholic & traditional. regarding each person as a unique expression of Christ, and therefore lovable.
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.