Australian Catholics: majority in favour of S/S Marriage (?)

Catholics defy church leadership to become biggest backers of same-sex marriage: poll

Michael Koziol

A majority of Catholics, Christians and other religious groups support same-sex marriage and are inclined to vote for it in the forthcoming postal survey, according to new polling commissioned by advocates.

The “yes” side starts the campaign with the backing of 66 per cent of all Australians, with support among the non-religious at 79 per cent, compared with 58 per cent among people of faith, the research shows.

‘Largest ever’ rally for marriage equality
More than 20,000 people took to the streets of Melbourne on Saturday, with placards, rainbow flags and balloons.

Catholics and non-Christian religions were more likely to support same-sex marriage, with two thirds of both those groups indicating they were in favour. For Anglicans, Uniting Church and Church of England, the figure was 59 per cent.

Marriage equality advocates will use the findings to encourage Australia’s 5 million Catholics to ignore directives from the church’s leadership and instead vote with their conscience.

Archbishop Denis Hart wants Catholics to vote ”no”.

The polling was commissioned by the Equality Campaign. It was conducted last week by Jim Reed of Newgate Research, formerly of Liberal-aligned Crosby/Textor, and surveyed 1000 people online.

They were asked: “If you were to vote, do you think that you would vote ‘yes’ or ‘no’ to allowing same-sex couples to marry in Australia?” Respondents had to choose between “yes” and “no”.

Mr Reed said the margin of error within each religious category was up to 8 per cent. But even at the maximum margin of error, a majority of people in each group supported same-sex marriage. The overall margin of error was 3 per cent.


The results echoed a survey by Crosby/Textor in 2014, which also found two-thirds of Catholics backed same-sex marriage, and put the overall level of support at 72 per cent.

“It really confirms a lot of the other published polls that around two-thirds, that is a majority, are intending to vote yes,” Mr Reed told Fairfax Media.

“What we’re seeing in this latest poll is confirmation that there is a majority support for same-sex marriage, even when they’re given the very real decision of a vote rather than more general ideological support.

“They give an indication certainly that a majority of people of the major faiths also support same-sex marriage and probably will do so in this vote.”

Last Sunday, Fairfax Media revealed the Catholic Church was threatening to sack any of its 180,000 teachers, nurses and other parish employees who entered a same-sex marriage if it were to be legalised.

Subsequently, Archbishop of Melbourne Denis Hart issued a collective call to arms, telling followers in a letter: “It is vital that we Catholics vote, so that our views can be heard on this vital public issue.”

But the polling suggests the Catholic leadership is out of touch with its base, 66 per cent of whom said they were inclined to vote for same-sex marriage in the coming postal survey.

“The upper management of the church isn’t listening to the flock,” said Tiernan Brady, executive director of the Equality Campaign and a practising Catholic. “The flock have made their mind up on this, they support marriage equality.”

Monica Doumit, spokeswoman for the Coalition for Marriage, said despite the poll results people of faith “continue to be concerned” about the implications of same-sex marriage for religious freedom.

“This is about more than the narrow protections offered to professional clergy,” she said. Rather, it was about the ability for religious people to express their view on marriage without fear of intimidation.

Unlike the Anglican Archbishop of Melbourne, whose plea to Australian Anglicans was to exercise their conscience in voting for or against Same-Sex Marriage; the Roman Catholic Archbishop, Denis Hart, seems to have found it necessary to warn Catholics that they should be voting against the proposal.

Perhaps the most surprising thing about this Australian research is that it has found more outright support for Same-Sex Marriage from Roman Catholics than from Anglicans. Given that the polling agency admits to a margin of error of up to 8% within each religious body; the overall number of religious people voting for the measure obviously has the Roman Catholic Church concerned for its influence.

Father Ron Smith, Christchurch, New Zealand

About kiwianglo

Retired Anglican priest, living in Christchurch, New Zealand. Ardent supporter of LGBT Community, and blogger on 'Thinking Anglicans UK' site. Theology: liberal, Anglo-Catholic & traditional. regarding each person as a unique expression of Christ, and therefore lovable.
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Australian Catholics: majority in favour of S/S Marriage (?)

  1. Brian Ralph says:

    I spent 15 years teaching, while an Anglican, in a senior Catholic boys high school in South west Sydney. For almost 10 of those years my sexuality was known. Later I spent another 8 years at a Catholic junior high school in Western Sydney (Diocese of Parramatta). While I was more circumspect, I am told my sexuality was no secret. During my time at the first school I actively campaigned for homosexual law reform (achieved in1984). The TV News outed me sitting in a public meeting. I was told the School authorities knew of my activities and, as long as I was not too public, they preferred to ignore them. While there was the occasional complaint from a parent, I was supported by the (brother) principals, staff and most of the students.
    I use to joke that I would never be employed in an Anglican (Sydney Diocese) school. I discovered most Catholics are willing to rely on their own judgement when receiving directives from priests and bishops.

  2. kiwianglo says:

    Yes, Brian. Roman Catholics are well known for following their own consciences on a range of issues – not least that of the use of contraception Catholics are not idiots, and they realise that a ‘group conscience’ can never outlaw the individual conscience. The primacy of the individual conscience is a most important human right.

  3. Brian Ralph says:

    I would also draw your attention to statements by the principals of the two leading Jesuit Schools in Australia

    I have always had the greatest regard for the Jesuits. It was a Jesuit priest who first told me (probably about 1979) that. although an Anglican, I was welcome to participate in the Mass as I was a member of the school community.

    By the way, now that I am a dual citizen, the current ridiculous events in Australia have made me consider destroying my Australian passport. I only use it when entering and leaving Australia. I describe myself as Aussie by birth, Kiwi by choice.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.