Church in Wales Challenged on non-appointment to Llandaff

Church investigates official complaints into homophobia against gay cleric

Insiders have lodged an official complaint after a gay cleric was barred from being appointed Bishop of Llandaff.

Five members of the Church in Wales’ secretive electoral college that debates and votes for candidates have spoken of ‘deeply inappropriate’ references to Dr Jeffrey John’s homosexuality when considering his nomination, Christian Today can reveal.

In a letter to the Church’s most senior executive Simon Lloyd, the electors said the remarks against Dr John ‘prejudiced’ the process making it ‘invalid’.

A formal investigation has now been launched into the process and a legal panel chaired by a judge will decide whether to scrap the decision not to take Dr John’s nomination forward.

The electoral body met in Llandaff Cathedral for three days but failed to elect a candidate despite Jeffrey John winning more than half the vote and unanimous support from local representativesWikipedia

The complaint signed by five of the 47-strong body read: ‘We object to the raising at electoral college of the matter of sexuality or civil partnership status, in direct contravention of the Church in Wales’s own policy that sexuality or civil partnership status is not a bar to appointment as a Bishop.

‘We consider that this action was deeply inappropriate, and prejudiced the electoral college proceedings so as to render them invalid.’

In response, Mr. Lloyd asked members of the electoral body to approve that normal rules of confidentiality should be waived to allow an investigation.

The appointment of a new bishop is now on hold and may be delayed until the investigation is complete. 

Mr. Lloyd told electors: ‘The timescale is a matter for the Legal Sub-Committee and is dependent upon the amount of analysis required and how many times they need to meet. The deliberations of the Committee cannot and should not be hurried.’

A statement from the Church in Wales read: ‘Five members of the Electoral College, which was assembled to elect the Bishop of Llandaff in February, have now submitted a complaint to the Secretary of the Electoral College. Their complaint is in relation to certain aspects of the conduct of the College. This matter has now been referred to the Legal Sub-Committee, which is a body in the Church in Wales assembled to consider legal and governance matters.

‘The responsibility of appointing the next Bishop of Llandaff has passed to the Bench of Bishops. It is too early to say whether the deliberations of the Legal Sub-Committee will have any effect on the timing of an announcement.’

Dr John, currently Dean of St Albans Cathedral, was nominated to be Bishop of Llandaff and despite winning more than half the votes and unanimous support from local electors, he narrowly missed out on the two-thirds needed to be appointed.

The decision was then passed to the Welsh Bench of Bishops who refused to reconsider his nomination in a new shortlist.

But in a letter following his dismissal, Dr. John said the only reason he was blocked was his sexuality.

‘The only arguments adduced against my appointment – in particular by two of the bishops – were directly related to my homosexuality and/or civil partnership – namely that my appointment would bring unwelcome and unsettling publicity to the diocese, and that it might create difficulties for the future Archbishop in relation to the Anglican Communion,’ he wrote in a highly unusual open letter to Bishop John Davies, the senior Church leader in Wales.

‘To ride roughshod of the very clearly expressed, unanimous view of a diocese in this way is extraordinary, unprecedented and foolish,’ he told Bishop Davies.

‘You decided, arbitrarily, to ignore the submissions that you had asked for, and to declare that those who were discussed at the Electoral College were now, in fact, no longer to be considered. This is a clear and ludicrous breach of process, and a further insult to the people of the diocese, and very many others who took the trouble to contribute their view.’

The Church in Wales strongly denies allegations of homophobia.

A statement from the Church read: ‘Neither homosexuality nor participation in a civil partnership is a bar to any candidate being either nominated or elected as a Bishop in the Church in Wales. Moreover, this was made clear to members of the Electoral College by its President, the Bishop of Swansea and Brecon.’


This is a Report from the newspaper ‘Christian Today’

In view of the brouhaha that has erupted since the (non) election of the New Bishop of  Llandaff in the Church of Wales; it seems logical that those who protested against the seeming prejudice of the Electoral College against the election of Saint Albans Dean Jeffrey John (native Welshman, theologian, and S/S partnered celibate clergyman) should challenge the Welsh House of Bishops’ determination to exclude any further consideration of Jeffrey John’s candidature.

Seen in the context of the Electoral College deliberations, which – despite participants being warned not to exercise prejudice on the grounds of  J/J’s homosexual status –  then went forward to actually exclude J/J from inclusion as a candidate.

It then seems natural that the ‘Five members of the Church in Wales’ secretive electoral college that debates and votes for candidates have spoken of ‘deeply inappropriate’ references to Dr Jeffrey John’s homosexuality when considering his nomination’ in their Letter to the General Secretary in the Church in Wales.

Father Ron Smith, Christchurch, New Zealand

About kiwianglo

Retired Anglican priest, living in Christchurch, New Zealand. Ardent supporter of LGBT Community, and blogger on 'Thinking Anglicans UK' site. Theology: liberal, Anglo-Catholic & traditional. regarding each person as a unique expression of Christ, and therefore lovable.
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Church in Wales Challenged on non-appointment to Llandaff

  1. Ty Gwyn says:

    Lest this error goes uncorrected, may I just say that the electoral college met to discuss the appointment of a new Bishop of Llandaff, not a new Bishop of Swansea (& Brecon). The Cathedral Church of Llandaff is in Cardiff, the capital of Wales.

    • kiwianglo says:

      Thank you, Ty Gwynn,

      How embarrassing! It may be as well that I do not have many people checking in on my blog.
      My sincere apologies to you, and the Church in Wales. My piece has now been corrected. Agape!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.