Church of Scotland plan for gay ministers offers possible ‘template’ for Anglicans
Church of England liberals hail Scottish ‘opt-out’ idea as possible breakthrough for divisions over homosexuality
Under plans agreed by the General Assembly, which is meeting in Edinburgh, congregations will be able to invite people in civil partnerships to become their minister without formally changing the Church of Scotland’s traditional teaching on sexuality and marriage.
Instead, those congregations will be able to “opt out” of that aspect of the Church’s teaching.
The outgoing Moderator of the Church of Scotland, the Very Rev John Chalmers
The Assembly will discuss whether a similar approach could be applied for same-sex marriage as civil partnerships later this week.
- Church of England should be made to allow gay clergy to marry – bishop
- Lesbian couple make history with first same-sex church wedding
South of the border, the Church of England already allows clerics to form civil partnerships as long as they claim to be celibate. But the Church of Scotland’s approach does not require celibacy.
The Very Rev David Arnott, who coordinates the General Assembly’s business, said that although the Presbyterian structure of the Church of Scotland is different from that of Anglican churches, he hoped the plan could offer a “template” for the Church of England to consider.
He told BBC Radio 4’s Sunday programme: “We are not going to change people’s minds, we have to come to a way of living together with our differences and living with our diversity and I hope that we’re able to do that.”
The Church of England has begun a process of “facilitated conversations” on the issue of sexuality following a call by the Archbishop of Canterbury the Most Rev Justin Welby to find a model of “mutual flourishing” for both sides rather than a vague compromise.
The Rev Sally Hitchiner
The Rev Sally Hitchiner, an Anglican priest and founder of “Diverse Church”, a group for young gay, lesbian, bisexual and transgender Christians, said the Church of England should “look carefully” at the Scottish arrangements.
“It sounds very similar to the Church of England’s policy on remarriage of divorcees and I think that works very well and actually I think that protects conservatives,” she said.
“In the conservative wing of the Church of England people genuinely are concerned that in 10 or 20 years they won’t be able to hold those views.
“If we can find a model like the Church of Scotland I think it could protect conservatives within the church while still allowing those of us who want to marry people of the same sex and indeed be married ourselves we should do so.”
Rev Andrew Foreshew-Cain (right) and Stephen Foreshew-Cain married last year
Canon Rosie Harper a prominent liberal cleric added: “This is a very interesting thing which at least makes what they doing overt rather than smoke and mirrors like it is in England.”
The Rev Andrew Foreshew-Cain, one of the first Church of England priests to enter a same-sex marriage, tweeted: “I am deeply glad that the Church of Scotland has followed where the Spirit of God is leading.”
“South of the border, the Church of England already allows clerics to form civil partnerships as long as they claim to be celibate. But the Church of Scotland’s approach does not require celibacy.”
This statement from the above article in The Telegraph proclaims the not-so-subtle difference between the current situation in the Church of England, and that now embraced by the (Presbyterian) Church of Scotland. The point at issue here is not the fact that clergy may be participants in Same-Sex legal relationships, but that, in the Church of England, at present, such clergy are expected to remain celibate, i.e. ‘non-sexual’.
The Church of Scotland maintains no such sexual taboo, which calls into question the place of the Church of England in clergy bedrooms.
However, it appears that the Church of Scotland is allowing parishes to opt-out of accepting a clergy-person on the basis of their partnered same-sex status. This allows a conscientious objection in a particular situation where a parish is united in opposition to clerical same-sex partnerships.
At this stage in the arguments about same-sex relationships among the clergy, at least the Church of Scotland is being honest about what same-sex partnerships may involve in the way of personal intimacy. In other words, it is not legislating for celibate clergy – an argument that still obtains in the Church of England for civilly-partnered clergy!
Father Ron Smith, Christchurch, New Zealand