Kelvin’s Blog – Heresy Hunting & Expediency

Heresy hunting

Posted: 14 May 2014 03:39 AM PDT

One of the big differences between the theological training that I received from the university and the theological training I received from the church was that the former was interested in heresy and the latter wasn’t interested at all.

It may be that things are different now, I don’t know. But quite a lot of the church history that we did when I first did my BD was about defining the limits of orthodoxy. In other words, looking at the controversies of the early church and learning about the key players who determined what was and what was not legitimate for Christians to believe in. And it was useful stuff too – far too easily dismissed by those who think the church should simply have fuzzy boundaries and for whom any theology goes. Useful too for helping one to think through the modern church’s controversies to see whether or not things have changed much.

It also led to the entertaining theological dinner party game of ‘I can’t believe that’s not orthodoxy’. The participants have to come up with a new heresy and the others have to prove that it is in fact an old one.

One way of understanding the trials and tribulations of modern Anglicanism is to see it as a global version of this game. And not just Anglicanism of course, though we are particularly good at it.

Current possible heresies include the following:

Optional Doctrinalism – the idea that a church can have a doctrine which it authorises some people to disbelieve. (This one seems very attractive at the moment – see the latest from New Zealand).

Clerical Morality – The idea that clergy have different moral standards put upon them than the laity. (Yes, this one can be found very clearly in lots of documents, not least the recent pastoral statement and guidance from the House of Bishops in England). The interesting question here is whether clerical celibacy, practised, for example, in some parts of the Roman Catholic Church at some times and in some places is a moral injunction or a pastoral one.

Canonical Antiadiaphoralism – Putting a contested doctrinal statement into the canons of a church by majority vote and then claiming it has creedal authority for all Christians for all time and in all places or claiming that statements which were made in canon law for one purpose actually apply in different circumstances but for for all people. (See for example, this statement by a group claiming to represent the Faith and Order Board of the Scottish Episcopal Church).

How are we to determine whether these are indeed modern heresies or whether they fall legitimately within orthodoxy?

The post Heresy hunting appeared first on What is in Kelvin’s Head?.


It seems to me, in agreement with Fr. Kelvin Holdsworth’s opinion here in his latest blog article, that the modern Church can be very selective about what is, and what is not, doctrinal heresy. I’m interested that Kelvin should cite the latest situation arising from our local ACANZP General Synod, here in New Zealand, that has just announced its decision on how to deal with a call for openness in our Church to Same-Sex Marriage Blessings, and the possibility of Blessing a Civil Partnership of Same-Sex members.

Having apologised publicly at the G.S. for the Church’s past dismissive attitude towards the LGBT community in the Church, and affirming the need of the Church to repent of such behaviour; there is still no provision to be made at this point in time for Same Sex Blessings – even though legally-married Same-Sex couples will not be denied access to the Sacraments of the Church. Despite this, there is a hint that, if a parish priest and his flock want to publicly recognise a Same-Sex relationship akin to marriage – they may do so, but only with the express permission of the local bishop. However, it must be stressed, there will be no opportunity for an official blessing.

The light at the end of the tunnel, for Same-Sex monogamously-partnered couples, is that a working group will be set up to further investigate the doctrinal situation of such relationships, with a view to reporting their findings to the next meeting of the general Synod in 2016. Any decision allowing for S/S Blessings (there is no prospect of celebrating S/S Marriage in the Church, because of a polity of ‘no-change’  on the current heterosexual model of marriage) would then be put to diocesan synods, to be brought back to the following meeting of the general Synod in 2018. By that time, many Same-Sex Couples may have given up on the Church ever bringing an official Blessing into their relationship.

Father Ron Smith, Christchurch, New Zealand

About kiwianglo

Retired Anglican priest, living in Christchurch, New Zealand. Ardent supporter of LGBT Community, and blogger on 'Thinking Anglicans UK' site. Theology: liberal, Anglo-Catholic & traditional. regarding each person as a unique expression of Christ, and therefore lovable.
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

1 Response to Kelvin’s Blog – Heresy Hunting & Expediency

  1. davidearle says:

    Another heresy that gets little attention these days is the Pelagian heresy. (In fact I only came across it recently and discovered it has the distinction of being rejected by the largest number of councils). Part of the Pelagian heresy is that we can overcome sin through our own efforts. Or a modern variant, that we must free ourselves of certain ‘sins’ or adopt certain standards of behaviour before we can experience the grace of God.
    As far as I understand any teaching that we must conform in our behaviour to a particular standard in order to experience God’s grace falls under this heresy. Making more than 2/3rds of the debate about the acceptance of the LGBT community 100% and utterly moot.
    And the other 1/3 of the debate rests on a misinterpretation of sin IMHO.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.