Costly Reconciliation – a Baghdad Priest’s View-point

Costly Reconciliation

  • Tuesday, May 6, 2014

When someone asked the Rev. Canon Andrew White why members are so happy at St. George’s Church in war-torn Baghdad, the response came from Lina, whom White considers his adopted Iraqi daughter: “When you’ve lost everything, Jesus is all you have left.”

The question was not a theoretical one for Canon White (more popularly known as the “Vicar of Baghdad”), his loved ones, or his parishioners. St. George’s Church is a cathedral that has suffered the loss of 1,276 congregants during the last decade. And yet he declares with joy and a tinge of wonder in his voice, “I have one of the most wonderful congregations you can imagine.”

Visiting Washington, D.C., to receive the Chuck Colson Center for Christian Worldview’s William Wilberforce Award, White spoke on “Reconciliation and Peacemaking in the World, Church, and the Anglican Communion” at Truro Anglican Church on May 1. He is the author of several books, including Father, Forgive: Reflections on Peacemaking (Monarch, 2013).

St. George’s is in many ways a center of reconciliation. It spends more than $11,000 a month on programs that include feeding the hungry, providing medical treatment, holding a weekly service for the small Jewish community in Baghdad (White studies a portion of the Torah with them), and often conducting Sunday worship in the midst of bombing.

Iraqis are “the most loving people,” he said, beaming. “For us who are torn apart from war, it is so important that we can be one.”

That unity is costly, however. “Reconciliation is very extreme. … It’s sitting down, eating, and loving people who have killed your people,” he told the Truro congregation. “So often I have had to meet with people who have killed my people. Peacemaking is not easy.”

Neither is being a Christian in Iraq. “The most devout [Iraqi] Christians have been born Christian,” White said in response to a question. “‘Nominal Christianity’ does not exist in Iraq.”

He does not baptize people because they might be killed in response; while he laments this curtailment, he takes comfort in that “I know they love Jesus.” He explained further to TLC that he celebrates the Eucharist safely because it does not evoke the hostility that baptism does as a sign of Christian identification.

White challenged his audience to think of all Iraqi people, not just Iraqi Christians, as suffering. He called the Iraqi government “very protective” of Christians. The desire to leave Iraq is widespread among Iraqis because the violence is directed against everyone; consequently, people will depart if they have the means. “I used to say to my people, ‘Don’t leave me,’” he admitted, but his love for them and concern for their safety now override his feelings.

Throughout his talk and the ensuing question-and-answer session, White aimed to rectify misunderstandings related to reconciliation. He cautioned the audience not to dismiss him or others involved in his ministry as “woolly liberals.”

Theologically, he affirmed, “We believe totally in what the creed says — we don’t doubt it.” More broadly, he expressed his belief that Christian liberals and conservatives can find common ground: “We believe in one God — that is the biggest common denominator.”

And while reconciliation involves loving enemies in obedience to Jesus’ command, it “doesn’t just mean that you’re being nice to them,” but that you commit to working with them “until together you find peace.”

White also encouraged Truro parishioners to “be good to your rector” because it is “very difficult to walk the lonely road of reconciliation.” Truro is part of the Anglican Church in North America; its rector, the Rev. Tory Baucum, has drawn criticism for pursuing reconciliation and peacemaking with the Rt. Rev. Shannon Johnston, Bishop of Virginia.

Amid current Anglican Communion tensions, reconciliation does not mean avoiding differences: “We have to be very firm about what we believe and what we feel the Church should believe,” White told TLC. This stance must, however, be coupled with “loving those you believe are wrong.” He believes that despite the large element of risk involved in such an approach, reconciliation is “the only way forward” for the Communion.

Anglican tensions, however, are not pressing matters to Canon White’s parishioners. “The Anglican Communion means nothing to our people in Iraq,” he told TLC. The work there has been costly to the Vicar of Baghdad, whose work gives him little time with his wife and two sons, and who suffers from multiple sclerosis.

Still, as he told the Truro audience, he has been “greatly blessed” by stem-cell treatment he receives in Iraq that is unavailable elsewhere. Furthermore, he remains convinced that “the challenge of reconciliation is something all of us are called to” — a challenge that the ministries at St. George’s attempt to meet.

Ralph Webb


This ‘Living Church’ article by Ralph Webb, gives a compelling story of what is involved in the every-day life of the ‘Vicar of Baghdad’, Canon Andrew White, of St. George’s Cathedral in war-torn Iraq. When one hears of the heroic fortitude of such an Anglican cleric – staying with his vulnerable and diminishing congregation in a zone of continued ethnic/religious  conflict – one cannot but hear, more clearly, the message of the Gospel’s reconciling grace under extreme pressure.

Fr. Andrew’s personal life – afflicted as he is by a serious illness while yet ministering to the deep needs of other people – has been turned upside-down with the exigencies of trying to maintain a vital faith community in a situation of hostile religious conflict. And yet, despite the daily problems of existence, this indefatigable priest of our Church still believes in the need to love one’s enemies with the love of Christ.

This makes Fr. Andrew’s testimony to the need for reconciliation of Anglicans – despite the present difficulties of inter-provincial hostility and differences of opinion on matters of gender and sexuality – to be more important than cultural or spiritual apartheid. His visit to the ACNA parish of Truro, whose pastor is The Revd. Tony Baucum – a known advocate of reconciliation with the TEC Bishop of Virginia in the USA – must surely have helped this ACNA parish to better understand the disadvantage of intentional schismatic breakaway. Whether, or not, the broader hierarchy of both ACNA and TEC will take practical steps to pursue any attempt at reconciliation remains to be seen. However, the experience of this visiting leader of the Anglican Community in Baghdad should cause them to ponder on their situation.

Father Ron Smith, Christchurch, New Zealand

About kiwianglo

Retired Anglican priest, living in Christchurch, New Zealand. Ardent supporter of LGBT Community, and blogger on 'Thinking Anglicans UK' site. Theology: liberal, Anglo-Catholic & traditional. regarding each person as a unique expression of Christ, and therefore lovable.
This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

1 Response to Costly Reconciliation – a Baghdad Priest’s View-point

  1. murraysmallbone says:

    A truly wonderful witness by Fr. Andrew!
    Suffering and embracing it;we embrace Our Lord and find The Way forward.

    Fr. Ron, you mentioned “intentional schism”; very well put. Such schism is a luxury of indulgence and not Embracing Christ.

    Jesu mercy! Mary pray.!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.