G. S. Primates to offer “Alternative Oversight’ to dissident Anglicans

South offers global oversight

by Tim Wyatt – ‘CHURCH TIMES’ – Posted: 28 Feb 2014 @ 12:25

SHUTTERSTOCK
Click to enlarge

PRIMATES from the Global South of the Anglican Communion have announced that they intend to offer pastoral oversight to dissenting parishes and dioceses in other provinces.

After a meeting on 14 and 15 February in Cairo of archbishops and bishops from Africa, South America, and Asia, the Global South Primates’ steering committee released a statement declaring its plan to create a “Primatial oversight council”.

The statement, which was not signed by the representative of the Primate of All Nigeria, also accused the Episcopal Church in the US and the Anglican Church of Canada of causing “broken relations, a lack of trust, and dysfunctional ‘instruments of unity'” within the Communion since 2003, the year in which the Rt Revd Gene Robinson, an openly gay man, was appointed Bishop of New Hampshire in the US.

The Primates wrote that they believed the time had come to “reshape the instruments of unity” to create a Church that was more accountable. They also called on the Archbishop of Canterbury to call a Primates’ Meeting in 2015 “in order to address the increasingly deteriorating situation facing the Anglican Communion.

“It is important that the agenda of this Primates’ Meeting be discussed and agreed upon by the Primates beforehand in order to ensure an effective meeting.”

Archbishop Welby, who intends to visit every Primate during his first 18 months as Archbishop, was present at the Cairo meeting, together with his director of reconciliation Canon David Porter.

Asked for a statement afterwards, a Lambeth Palace spokesman declined to give Archbishop Welby’s reaction to the Primates’ move.

The Rt Revd Michael Doe, formerly Bishop of Swindon and general secretary of USPG, now Us., recently taught a session on the state of the Communion to overseas bishops at Canterbury Cathedral (News, 14 February). On Monday he criticised the statement, saying it amounted to an attempt to expand the authority of the Global South.

“Their statement misrepresents the role of the Communion-wide Primates’ Meeting. It is not a policy-making body,” he said. “There is no provision and no authority [for alternative oversight] in our kind of Communion.”

Bishop Doe also warned of the dangers of what he called “reverse colonialism”, where, as in the 19th century, one group of nations decides it has spiritual superiority and tells others how to behave.

He called for a return to a policy that acknowledged diversity and difference within the Communion, which was upheld at the last Primates’ Meeting in 2011.

The Global South statement also praised the “faithfulness” of the House of Bishops in the recently released pastoral guidance on same-sex marriage ( News, 21 February).

Assembly cancelled. The World Evangelical Alliance (WEA) has postponed its next General Assembly, planned for October in South Korea. A WEA statement focused on “recent internal divisions among the Evangelical community” in Korea, which made the Assembly “untenable”.

________________________________________________________________

The Statement from the Global South Primates Meeting, held in Cairo recently, that speaks of further incursions into the territory of other Anglican Communion Churches, where conservative dioceses and parishes may wish to align themselves with the anti-Gay policies of the GAFCON Provinces; marks out a new confrontational stance that has been described by the U.K. Head of the former USPG Anglican Missionary Society, as inimical to the Anglican Tradition and praxis. Bishop Michael Doe writes as  follows:

“Their statement misrepresents the role of the Communion-wide Primates’ Meeting. It is not a policy-making body,” he said. “There is no provision and no authority [for alternative oversight] in our kind of Communion.”

Bishop Doe (USPG) also warned of the dangers of what he called “reverse colonialism”, where, as in the 19th century, one group of nations decides it has spiritual superiority and tells others how to behave.

Considering the boldness of the G.S. Primates’ statement – issued AFTER  the G.S. Meeting that was attended by the Archbishop of Canterbury – which more or less demands a special meeting of the Anglican Communion Primates in 2015 – seems to imply the threat of unilateral action to provide Alternative Episcopal Oversight to Anglican parishes and dioceses in other provinces of the Communion, an action that would call into question the present Instruments of Unity within the Communion Structure.

In view of the recent passage of Anti-Gay laws in Nigeria and Uganda (part of the ‘Global South’ conglomerate) backed by the Primates of the Anglican Church in those countries – a state of affairs largely repugnant to Western Provinces of the Anglican Communion – this statement by the Global South Primates might signal the imminent break-up of the Anglican Communion; into a pro-Global South conservative Church, which maintains the ‘sola-Scriptura’ view of gender and sexuality (where Gays are criminalised and subject to harsh treatment) and the rest of the Provinces of the Communion that believe that Gay people are fellow bearers of the Image and Likeness of God, and due the respect that this status confers on all Christians.

It will be interesting to see the response of the Archbishop of Canterbury, and the non-G.S. Provinces of the Anglican Communion. Whatever happens with this G.S. initiative, it will very likely make little difference to the mission and ministry of Christ’s Gospel in the independent Provinces of the Anglican Communion that seek to further the cause of peace and justice in their own jurisdictions.

Father Ron Smith, Christchurch, New Zealand

Advertisements

About kiwianglo

Retired Anglican priest, living in Christchurch, New Zealand. Ardent supporter of LGBT Community, and blogger on 'Thinking Anglicans UK' site. Theology: liberal, Anglo-Catholic & traditional. regarding each person as a unique expression of Christ, and therefore lovable.
This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s