+Norwich Responds to Abps’ Letter on Same-Sex Partnerships

To all clergy
Dear Colleague,

You may well be already aware that, following a meeting of the House of Bishops on February 13th, the Archbishops have issued a pastoral letter signed on behalf of the House related to the introduction of same-sex marriage. The first such marriages in England will take place in a few weeks time.

The reporting of the letter and the appendix to it has been relatively limited in the national media, and some comments suggested the House of Bishops had taken a harsh line. Hence, it seems important to distribute the letter and its appendix directly to you. It is available, of course, through the Church of England’s website too. Got to http://www.churchofengland.org/media-centre/news/2014/02/house-of-bishops-pastoral-guidance-on-same-sex-marriage.aspx

The Bishops are clear that the Government’s introduction of same-sex marriage in this country should not, and ought not to, change our understanding of marriage as expressed in the Canons and the marriage liturgy of the Church of England. Nevertheless, there will be pastoral issues to be addressed in our parishes as a result of this change. The House of Bishops wanted to give some guidance now, even though there has also been recent agreement to promote facilitated conversations on issues related to same sex relationships in the light of the report by Sir Joseph Pilling, presented to the House of Bishops towards the end of last year.

The tone of the pastoral letter is as important as the text of the appendix which accompanies it. The appendix should not be read in isolation from the letter. Congregations are encouraged to welcome couples in same sex marriages and that will be a challenge for some parishes and clergy. The continued refusal to authorise a service of blessing after a same sex marriage or civil partnership will be a source of regret to others, though the House is clear that there are appropriate forms of prayer and pastoral support which can be offered to couples in such situations. Clergy are required to fashion their lives and ministries in accordance with the Canons of our Church (including Canon B30 on marriage) which is why the House believes contracting a same sex marriage conflicts with the Canons and disciplines of the Church in a way entering a civil partnership does not.

The letter and its appendix are described as “pastoral guidance”. The letter also refers to the demand of the gospel that “we all listen, speak and act with integrity, self-discipline and grace, acknowledging that as yet our knowledge and understanding are partial.”

I am very conscious that in this area my own understanding is inevitably partial. I shall seek to respond to any situations and issues which arise as a result of this advice with fidelity to Jesus Christ and his Church and, I pray, pastoral wisdom. Pray for me, as I pray for you.
Yours sincerely, (+ Graham Norvic)


The following paragraph, contained in this pastoral letter to the clergy in his diocese by +Graham James, the Bishop Norwich, is at the heart of what may be causing some unrest among the ranks of clergy and laity in the Church of England:

” Clergy are required to fashion their lives and ministries in accordance with the Canons of our Church (including Canon B30 on marriage) which is why the House believes contracting a same sex marriage conflicts with the Canons and disciplines of the Church in a way entering a civil partnership does not.”

What seems to be a particular issue of conflict is the fact that, though the Pilling report recommended the official provision of an arrangement for the Church Blessing of a Same-Sex Civil Partnership – which is not actually ‘marriage’ – this has been put out of bounds by the Archbishops’ Letter.

The Bishop of Norwich may also be concerned that, if any of his clergy have already entered into a Same-Sex Civil Partnership (and that is now allowed within the Church of England for clergy who promise to be celibate); if Civil Partnerships are withdrawn after the arrival of legal Same sex Marriage provisions by the government, and become ‘de facto’ Same-Sex Marriages; this would put the clergy into an awkward position with regard to their situation as clergy in a Church which does not allow clergy to avail themselves of Same-Sex Marriage.

Of course, there are other pastoral reasons for a review of the strong stance taken by the House of Bishops on the whole matter of Same-Sex Partnerships within the family of the Church that will need to be sorted before the Same-Sex Marriage Bill becomes effective in March 2014. One problem is that, if prayers can be said ‘over a couple’ in ‘thanksgiving for their partnership’; how is that different from an official Blessing?

It seems that Bishop Graham is doing his very best to avert disaster.

(This is written on the very day that our New Zealand Anglican Church (ACANZP) has ordained the first woman Bishop to have been ordained a priest in the Church of England)

Father Ron Smith, Christchurch, New Zealand

About kiwianglo

Retired Anglican priest, living in Christchurch, New Zealand. Ardent supporter of LGBT Community, and blogger on 'Thinking Anglicans UK' site. Theology: liberal, Anglo-Catholic & traditional. regarding each person as a unique expression of Christ, and therefore lovable.
This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.