Clergy: angels or enforcers?

Clergy: angels or enforcers?

Madeleine Davies

by Madeleine Davies – ‘CHURCH TIMES‘ Posted: 26 Apr 2013 @ 12:15

Click to enlarge

Liz Jump Team Vicar of Blackbourne, in the diocese of St Edmundsbury & Ipswich.

See ‘I took the test’, below.

THE clergy‘s is one of the few professions to show a higher level of care at work than in their personal lives, the findings of a psychometric test completed online by more than 80,000 people worldwide suggests. The drive to be obedient, however, is even stronger than the drive to care.

The MoralDNA test asks people to what extent they agree with a series of statements describing how they make decisions. For example: “I won’t take the easy option if it’s the wrong thing to do.” Some of these questions relate to the workplace. The answers are used to create a “MoralDNA profile” that reflects the user’s “decision-making preferences”: the ethics of obedience, care, and reason.

The ethic of care is defined as meaning “that what’s right is based on our humanity, empathy, and love for other people”. The ethic of obedience relates to “obeying or complying with reasonable rules, laws, policies, and procedures”. The ethic of reason relates to “what we judge is right”.

The “corporate philosopher” who designed the test, Roger Steare, said: “In almost all cases, people report a reduced ethic of care at work, either because they are told to behave in a certain way or because they have to put the interests of their employer over the needs of the customer.”

The only professions that report a “slight increase” in the ethic of care at work were those whose work came under the heading of Homemaker, Religion, or Healthcare, who dealt directly with caring for people. Professions at the bottom of the table for the ethic of care include chemicals, politics, oil and gas, and the armed services.

People who complete the test are assigned to one of six MoralDNA “character types”: philosopher, judge, angel, teacher, enforcer, or guardian. The most common type for those working in religion, Mr Steare said on Monday, was “enforcer”, defined as “the people we rely on to make sure that everyone obeys the rules”. He said: “Generally speaking, there is a leader to whom you are answerable. Dissent is frowned upon. Even though they care more than average, they are more obedient than many. Obedience will overcome that sense of care.”

This was “concerning”, he said, and a “strong argument for having more women as religious leaders: generally speaking, they will put care above reason and obedience”.


I took the test

‘I’m an angel, and that’s official – at least, according to the MoralDNA survey. A series of agree/disagree statements generate a result that describes your moral “coding”; and “Angels”, unsurprisingly, put care for others first.

Given that the questions ask how you make decisions, and what guides your thinking at work, as well as in private, I’m not surprised that, as a Vicar, I should come out as believing that care for the other is primary. So far, so good.

But can morality be condensed into simple questions and answers? What about context? The “what ifs?” of life, meaning decisions that we would make in the abstract, can become blurred and confused once real people, and the fuzzy edges of life, appear.

I do, however, find myself trying to categorise my colleagues, and I might suggest that they all try this. Anything that helps us to understand how we view the world, and take our places within it, is worth a look.’

Liz Jump
Team Vicar of Blackbourne, in the diocese of St Edmundsbury & Ipswich


A rather interesting article today from the English ‘Church Times’.

I knew God must have had a particular reason for wanting women to become priests and bishops in the Church. In this psychometric test – a Moral/DNA Survey –  women clergy have been singled out from men as more inclined to put the exercise of ‘duty of Care‘ above ‘duty of Obedience’. I guess, too, that might be the very reason why Roman Catholics will never be able to ordain women (tongue out of cheek!).

Father Ron Smith, Christchurch, New Zealand

About kiwianglo

Retired Anglican priest, living in Christchurch, New Zealand. Ardent supporter of LGBT Community, and blogger on 'Thinking Anglicans UK' site. Theology: liberal, Anglo-Catholic & traditional. regarding each person as a unique expression of Christ, and therefore lovable.
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Clergy: angels or enforcers?

  1. Brian Rountree says:

    Wel, that was an interesting test. No news to me, I’m an Enforcer!

  2. Good on you, Brian. I’m not sure you’ll get total backing from Pope Francis on this – once he’s cleared the decks at the Vatican.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.